Categories: Uncategorized

Questions about Oakland’s gang injunction

Evidence opened yesterday in the City of Oakland’s gang injunction lawsuit. In that lawsuit, City Attorney John A. Russo seeks to restrict the activities of 40 alleged gang members within a 450-square-block area, mostly in the Fruitvale neighborhood of Oakland. If successful, the gang injunction won’t just bar criminal conduct. Within the 450-block area designated as a safety zone, it would impose a curfew and restrict the associational rights of the persons named in the injunction.

I am sympathetic to the frustration that Oakland residents feel, but I have several questions.

– Will the Norteño gang relocate to another neighborhood?
– How much does policing the gang injunction rules cost? Would that money be better spent on recalling laid off Oakland police officers, youth programs, and education?
– Will publicly branding people as “gang” members drive them further into gang life?
– What about people who aren’t gang members? Sure, those who are not gang members or no longer gang members can always file papers in court contesting their gang status. But that would require a lawyer, something that someone trying to make good working a minimum wage job at Costco can hardly afford. Repudiating a gang to get off of the “gang list” could also incur retaliation.

Published by
Alanna D. Coopersmith

Recent Posts

Supreme Court strikes down unaffordable bail

The much-awaited case In re Humphrey was decided last week by the California Supreme Court.…

3 years ago

New California Law, AB 1950, Shortens Probation

Effective as law on January 1 of 2021, California Assembly Bill 1950 places strict limits…

3 years ago

Fourth Amendment Right to Privacy

I recently learned that a friend who is African-American has been detained by the police…

3 years ago

Can a DUI be a Felony?

A routine question I ask my new clients is whether they’ve ever been convicted of…

4 years ago

Legacy of Exonerations

Check out the National Registry of Exonerations. This database, which is jointly sponsored by the…

4 years ago

Goodbye to the Felony-Murder Rule

To be guilty of murder, don’t you have to kill someone? You would think. After…

6 years ago